Rev. Shawn Garan
  • Home
  • Before the Canon
  • Media
    • Books
    • Music
  • Reading
  • Pastoral & Leadership Coaching
Picture
A series based on the book by Norman Vincent Peale, The Power of Positive Thinking. I pray it helps you live a more empowered life.

We Kept the Work and Lost the Song

9/22/2026

0 Comments

 
Some art from my Moleskine along with my Hobbes :). 
Carl Jung on technology, the human psyche, and the drum we forgot how to hear

So I have a confession to make. I love notebooks. Not in a casual, "oh, that's a nice notebook" sort of way. I mean I love them the way some people love vintage cars, which is to say irrationally and at great personal expense. Moleskines especially. There is something about the weight of a good notebook in your hand, the texture of the paper, the way a fresh one sits there looking at you like it knows something is about to happen. And I love the smell of a notebook. Crack open a new Moleskine and breathe in those fresh pages, and you will know what I mean. (If you do not know what I mean, once you try it, you'll know.) I often write in them with a fountain pen, so by the end of a good day my fingers are usually stained with ink or pencil. Ink-stained hands make me feel like I've been down in the depths and come back up carrying something. You do not get that feeling from a keyboard. Nobody has ever come home with Wi-Fi on their fingers.
​
Almost everything I write in my notebooks ends up in my digital calendar too. I time block my days on paper, then dutifully enter the whole thing a second time on a screen. It's completely redundant.

Any productivity expert would tell me to pick one and move on.
Any productivity expert would be right. I refuse anyway.

Because the notebook isn't just about scheduling. It's where my sermon ideas show up half-formed and chaotically thought out. It's where I keep my journal to reflect on what the heck I'm doing with my life. It's where I scribble down my dreams in the morning before I forget. It's where I doodle and let my body speak. Oddly enough, when I block out my day by hand, I don't feel so boxed in. I feel free.

The calendar on my phone tells me where I have to be.
The notebook reminds me who I am while I'm getting where I have to be.

Please don't mistake me for some kind of Luddite. I love technology. I got the iPad the first day it came out and used a Palm Pilot back in the day. I'm a tech nerd (I used to play WoW for those who know). And a good share of my day runs through a screen but somewhere along the way I noticed the screen had started running me a bit more than I liked, and the notebook became my small act of rebellion. A way of keeping a little piece of my life in my own hands. With ink on them.

So you can imagine my reaction when I opened my copy of Jung's The Symbolic Life the other day and happened upon a two-page letter titled "The Effect of Technology on the Human Psyche." It felt a little like being caught, like Samuel, I couldn't let it just pass so I read some words written by a Swiss psychiatrist who has been dead since 1961. He also likely never imagined I would have read his, what we would call today, e-mails. Sorry Carl :*( but thank you! If someone rummages through my e-mails in the future, you are welcome for the nuggets of gold but please forgive me if you happen upon my texts, particularly with other ministers and therapists, we're only human.

A Letter to Some Engineering Students
In September of 1949, the editors of the student magazine at the Federal Polytechnic Institute in Zurich, which is basically the MIT of Switzerland but with better chocolate, wrote to Jung with a simple question: what does technology do to the human soul?

Jung's reply runs five short paragraphs (Collected Works 18, paras. 1403 to 1407). He opens by telling the students, more or less, "Great question. Terrible question. Good luck to us both." And then, in less space than it takes our church bulletin to list the week's announcements, he says something I think we desperately need to hear seventy-seven years later, while holding a phone in one hand and chatting with an AI in the other. (Guilty.)

The Song We Lost
Jung begins with a point we tend to forget. Technology did not arrive from outer space. We made it. It lives inside the human story, not outside of it. Which means there must be something in us that was built to meet it.

He finds that something in a surprising place. Most technological work, he says, is the same rhythmic motion repeated over and over. That happens to be the exact shape of the oldest human labor: grinding grain, pulling oars, hauling nets, swinging hammers. But here's the thing. Nobody ever did that work in silence. It always came with a rhythm and a chant.

Our ancestors did not merely endure monotony. They sang it. They drummed it. Jung says the person living close to instinct could tolerate an astonishing amount of repetition, even find it fascinating, because the rhythm took them somewhere. With the drum going, the worker might rise into something close to ecstasy, or drift into a pleasant, half-conscious trance, which Jung notes was not so bad either. (Anyone who has ever sat through a long committee meeting knows the second option well.) Either way, the monotony became a doorway.

Then Jung asks the question at the heart of the whole letter. What happens when we impose those ancient rhythms on modern people who have lost the ability to go anywhere with them?
Here is how I would put it.
​

We kept the work.
We lost the song.


I spent four years in the Coast Guard, and I can tell you every sailor understands this. There's a reason sea shanties exist, and trust me, it's not because sailors were all frustrated Broadway performers. Try cleaning up for a hundred people after a drug bust, then moving straight on to stripping and waxing the decks. You don't get through that on willpower. You get through it singing like madmen, letting rhythm and instinct carry you past the fatigue. It's how we marched for hours in boot camp, too, singing together in step. Years later, when I joined a protest in support of George Floyd, I felt the same thing. The chants and songs held the whole crowd together and kept us, for the most part, in step. That's how many become one. You need a rhythm bigger than you are. Now consider the rhythmic, repetitive work most of us do today: scrolling, clicking, answering, refreshing, and scrolling some more. Nobody has ever written a shanty about clearing their inbox. We are doing the most ancient kind of labor with none of the ancient medicine.

The Fallow Field
Jung's diagnosis follows. For modern people, he says, technology creates an imbalance, and that imbalance breeds dissatisfaction, with work and with life itself. It cuts us off from the natural range of what a human being is made to do. A lot of our natural instincts just go unused, like a field nobody bothers to plant. And the result, he says, is that we start to resent work itself.

Have you ever finished a day at the computer completely wiped out, even though the heaviest thing you lifted was a coffee mug? Your shoulders and back hurt and you barely moved? That is what Jung is describing. The exhaustion is not from effort. It is from one-sidedness. Most of you has been sitting in the dark all day, like a benchwarmer who never gets called into the game, and it is tired of waiting.

His proposed cure is gloriously Swiss. Move the factories out of the cities, work a four-hour day, and spend the rest of your time farming your own land. He even admits this may only work in Switzerland, and not anytime soon. It's hard not to smile. I tried pitching the four-hour day to myself once. My calendar took one look and said, "Are you crazy?"
​

But underneath the charm is a principle I believe with my whole heart: the answer to a one-sided life is not to destroy the side that dominates. That's dualism. That's splitting. It's easy, and it ignores how nuanced reality actually is. So what's the better way? Feed the parts of you that have been starving.

The Snake Eating Its Tail
The most important move in the letter comes next. On its own terms, Jung says, technology is "neither good nor bad, neither harmful nor harmless" (para. 1406). Whether it serves good or evil depends entirely on the attitude of the person using it.

If he had stopped there, that would be the tired old line that "tools are neutral," the kind of thing people say right before buying something they do not need. But Jung doesn't stop there. He adds that this attitude is one "which in turn depends on technology."

Read that again, slowly, the way you would read the fine print on a car lease. We are not neutral shoppers standing outside our tools, calmly deciding how to use them. Our tools are shaping the very minds doing the deciding. The attitude that governs our technology is itself being formed by our technology. It is a loop, and we are standing inside it, holding a charger.

Many of you know I wear a ring with the ouroboros on it, the serpent swallowing its own tail. It is my personal symbol, and I have loved it since I was a kid, which tells you everything you need to know about what kind of kid I was. In Jung's world the ouroboros is an image of wholeness, the circle that feeds and renews itself. But a circle can turn in two directions. It can be the loop of a life that keeps coming home to its center, or the loop of a life that keeps feeding on itself until there is nothing left to eat. Our relationship with our devices is an ouroboros. The only question is which kind.

I think about this the way I think about Cesar Millan (Yes, I watch the Dog Whisperer). A dog that yanks on the leash is not a bad dog. It is acting out a learned pattern because it does not know another way. Cesar does not scold the dog. He calmly breaks the pattern, and then, in that lost little moment when the dog has no idea what to do next, he shows it a new way. We are not bad people for being glued to our phones. We have been trained, and we are acting out the training. The work is to break the pattern and have something better waiting in the gap. Ideally something that does not require a charger.

The Engineer on the Couch
Jung then turns to the students themselves, the engineers in training. The technologist, he says, has the same problem as the factory worker. He spends his days with mechanical things and risks letting the rest of his mind waste away. Just as a bad diet damages the body over time, an imbalance in the psyche does damage in the long run and has to be compensated.

Compensation is one of Jung's great ideas, and I lean on it as an analyst. The psyche is self-correcting. When our conscious life gets too narrow, the unconscious pushes back. It sends us dreams, moods, restlessness, symptoms, and sudden strange fascinations, all tugging us toward whatever we have been ignoring. The soul, it turns out, is a very persistent widow when we ignore her. It does not care whether you have notifications turned off. As Paul noted, the spiritual life is like marriage, and trust me our soul is like a partner you think you can get away with ghosting. It ain't going to happen.

Jung says that in his practice he noticed engineers very often developed an interest in philosophy, and he calls this "an uncommonly sound reaction." I love that. The engineer who wakes up at fifty and suddenly cannot stop reading about the meaning of life is not having a crisis. An AI engineer suddenly resigns. Their soul is doing its job. The world may say, "that make no sense," but it does to that person.

And then comes my favorite part of the letter. Jung says this is why he always recommended that the Polytechnic keep a faculty of the humanities. Not to force every engineer into a philosophy seminar, but simply to remind the students that such things exist, so they could come back to them later in life if they ever felt the need.

What a humble, wise hope. Don't force it. Just leave the door visible. Put up a few signposts, so that when the soul starts aching for the rest of the house, people know where to walk. That was my whole philosophy when I did youth ministry, "make sure they remember this place was cool and not boring."

Friends, that's part of what the church is for. I've never believed the church is a courtroom. It's an outpost, an oasis in the middle of a very dry and very fast civilization. We are a humanities department planted in the middle of the machine, with better coffee hour. We keep the old songs. We keep the rhythm of the seasons: Advent and Lent and Easter and that long green stretch of summer with sending off and gathering days. We keep the chant, sometimes quite literally. We're here to remind people that these things exist, so that when their one-sided lives start demanding compensation, and they will, there is a room somewhere on a Sunday morning where people are singing together. A room where people stand and sit and pray side by side, and connect with one another through rituals and rites, creeds and a shared life.

A Question Only Experience Can Answer
Jung saves his most sobering word for last, and here the jokes stop for a moment. Technology, he says, is no more dangerous than any other development in human consciousness. The real danger is not in the tools we have. It's in what is still waiting to be discovered. Every new discovery will be used for harm as well as for good. Writing just four years after Hiroshima, he notes that we have already come very close to destroying ourselves with the atom bomb.

So, he says, we have to ask whether human beings have enough reason to resist the temptation to use these things destructively, or whether our nature will simply sweep us into catastrophe. And then he ends with no comfort at all. It is, he says, "a question which experience alone can answer."

I cannot read that sentence in 2026 without thinking about artificial intelligence. Every generation gets its own version of the atom bomb question, and ours may be the question of what we will do with the minds we have built. Jung's framing still holds. The machine is not the danger. The danger is an unconscious human being holding the machine.

I have come to believe that most of the harm in this world comes not from malice but from unconsciousness. People are rarely monsters. Mostly we are asleep. And a shadow we have never faced will always find a tool. That's not a technology problem. That's a spiritual problem, and it's now our problem. Which is why I keep saying, to you and to myself, that the most important work any of us can do is our own inner work. The conversation begins and ends in us.

Jung's refusal to hand us a tidy answer is, I think, the most honest thing in the letter. We don't know how this ends but we'll find out by living it. We are the experiment...

Picking Up the Drum Again
So what do we do? I do not think Jung would tell us to throw our phones in the river. I certainly will not. I would only have to go fish mine out to call the church office, and I suspect our sexton has opinions about me wading into the Pomperaug.

But I do think he would ask us to refuse one-sidedness. To notice the neglected fields in our own lives and start planting them again. To get our hands dirty, or at least inky. To walk. To make something. To sing while we work, even badly. Especially badly. To pray with our bodies and not only our minds.

For me, it looks pretty ordinary. A few minutes of meditation every morning. Twenty pushups and some leg lifts. Half an hour of real reading, the kind with paper. A notebook full of dreams and half-finished sermon ideas. Music while I make my bed and pick up after myself. None of it is heroic. But music, reading, chores, and meditation are how my everyday mind stays on speaking terms with my inner mind. They are my drum. They keep me centered in who I am.

And I would ask you to take your own restlessness seriously. The vague dissatisfaction. The sudden hunger for poetry, or silence, music, nature, fellowship, or God, that shows up out of nowhere at forty-seven years old, usually on a Tuesday, staring at the bird feeder in your window when you should be working. Those are not malfunctions. That is your soul trying to restore its balance. That is the psyche remembering the song.

The drum has gone quiet in most of our workplaces. But it has not gone quiet in us. The rhythm is still there, underneath all the noise, waiting to be heard. The invitation, as always, is to wake up and listen. And maybe buy a notebook. Smell it first. Trust me.

Source: C. G. Jung, "The Effect of Technology on the Human Psyche," in The Symbolic Life: Miscellaneous Writings, Collected Works, vol. 18, trans. R. F. C. Hull (Princeton: Princeton University Press, Bollingen Series), paras. 1403 to 1407. Originally a letter of 14 September 1949 to the editors of the Zürcher Student, published in the November 1949 issue.
0 Comments

    S.M.Garan

    The ramblings of a minister and psychotherapist who helps people hear the voice of the Soul, the Christ within.

    Picture

    Archives

    September 2026
    July 2026
    May 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025

    Categories

    All
    Ai
    Alchemical Christianity
    Alchemy
    Ancientchristianity
    Anima
    Archetype
    Archetypes
    Archons
    Bestill
    Bible
    Christ
    Christianity
    Collective Unconscious
    Collectiveunconscious
    Consciousness
    Cosmic Tree
    Creation Of Consciousness
    Depth Psychology
    Early Christianity
    Ed Edinger
    Edinger
    Elaine Pagels
    Encounter
    Experience
    Faithandpsychology
    Father
    Father Archetype
    Feminine
    Gnostic
    Gnosticism
    God
    Gospelofthomas
    Holy Spirit
    Inner Christianity
    Isha Kriya
    Jung
    Jungianpsychology
    Jung On Christianity
    Khidir
    Lectiondivina
    Lostcoin
    Lostsheep
    Luke15
    Meditation
    Mentalhealth
    Michael Williams
    Mother
    Mother-complex
    Murray Stein
    Myth
    Nag Hammadi
    Polymath
    Psalms
    Psyche
    Psychology
    Psychology And Religion
    Rebirth
    Religion
    Resonance
    Ressurection
    Richard Smoley
    Roosevelt
    Rumi
    Sadhguru
    Scriptureandpsyche
    Self
    Shadow
    Shambhavi Mahamudra
    Shams
    Sophia
    Soul
    Soul Work
    Soulwork
    Sundaysermon
    Symbolism
    Syzygy
    Technology
    Tesla
    Thedescent
    The Mother
    The Sacred Psyche
    The Symbolic Life
    Vibration
    Von Fronz
    Yoga

    RSS Feed

testing
Follow me here on TikTok: ​https://www.tiktok.com/@shawngaran
shawngaran.com
  • Home
  • Before the Canon
  • Media
    • Books
    • Music
  • Reading
  • Pastoral & Leadership Coaching